assetbest 
“When is whole life insurance a good investment for someone?”
Life insurance sparks strong opinions. Some experts insist only on term life, while many insurance agents praise whole life as a long-term choice and treat term as a temporary stopgap. Having worked in both personal finance and as a life insurance agent, I’ll say plainly: it depends.
At its core, life insurance replaces income for your dependents if you die while the policy is active. There are various types, and a handy way to think about the main difference between term and whole life is to compare renting versus buying a house.
Term life is like renting: you buy coverage for a set period—10, 20, or 30 years are common—and pay a fixed premium for that term. If you buy a 15-year, $500,000 policy, you pay the same annual premium for those 15 years, and if you die during that time your beneficiary receives $500,000. Term is much cheaper when you’re young, but premiums rise as you age, slowly at first and then much faster. Studies suggest only a small percentage of term policies ever pay a death benefit, often because people outlive the term or cancel the policy. In short, term delivers a lot of coverage for a relatively small cost.
Whole life is like buying a house: it’s permanent. Premiums are higher but don’t increase unless you cancel the policy, and the benefit is guaranteed to pay out if the policy remains in force. Whole life also builds cash value, which grows over time and can be borrowed against or used for retirement income. Unlike home equity, the cash value typically has a guaranteed growth rate that won’t go negative, so it behaves more like a safe savings vehicle than a market investment. Loans from the policy are generally tax-free, and if you surrender the policy you’re taxed only on the gains.
If you asked me on the street which to choose, I’d say term—because without knowing your situation it’s the safer default. That doesn’t mean term is best for everyone. Whole life can make sense in certain circumstances, and whether it’s a good “investment” depends on what you compare it to and the costs involved. Often it’s wiser to separate insurance from investing rather than expect one product to do both well.
Some people aren’t ready to commit to whole life or prefer other ways to meet their goals, and for many, term will be the better fit. The key is to understand your goals, learn about the options from multiple sources, and talk with a professional who can offer an outside perspective. One product may be right for one person and wrong for another—figure out what you want, weigh your choices, and pick what works best for your situation.
